Muslim Views Editorial Team
The brutal murder of Muhsin Hendricks has cast a dark shadow over the South African Muslim community. As we enter the sacred month of Ramadaan, this tragedy compels deep introspection.
Islam unequivocally condemns murder. The Quran declares: ‘If anyone slays a human being unless it be [in punishment] for murder or for spreading corruption on earth – it shall be as though he had slain all humankind.’ (Quran 5:32). This is not a matter of theological debate; it is a moral absolute.
There is no dispute in mainstream Islamic scholarship that same-sex relationships are haraam. Therefore, criticism of Hendricks’s advocacy for same-sex marriages is valid within Islamic jurisprudence. However, condemning an individual’s beliefs does not justify his murder. This incident highlights a greater crisis: the failure of Muslim leadership to engage meaningfully with individuals grappling with their identity within an Islamic framework. When nuanced discussions are absent, prejudice and extremism flourish. Islam calls for justice, and justice is never served by vigilantism.
The absence of institutional guidance on issues of sexuality has created a vacuum where fear, misinformation and hateful rhetoric thrive. We need structured theological engagement rooted in Quranic ethics, Prophetic teachings and classical scholarship. Public discourse must be shaped by knowledge, not reactionary sentiment. Our institutions must bridge the gap in understanding social ethics within an Islamic framework, offering guidance beyond simplistic condemnation.
Equally concerning is the lack of Muslim institutional structures offering integrated counselling that incorporates both professional therapy and faith-based guidance. At present, no dedicated organisation provides support for Muslims struggling with sexuality and identity while remaining committed to their faith. When the loudest voices focus solely on condemnation, fear replaces understanding. The Prophet Muhammad (SAWS) engaged with all members of society, even those in clear violation of divine law, with patience and unwavering commitment to Allah’s commands. His was a model of firmness in truth, never at the expense of mercy.
We must resist the climate of extremism that enables hateful rhetoric. Those who celebrated Hendricks’s murder must be reminded that such attitudes are deeply un-Islamic. The Prophet (SAWS) did not celebrate the downfall of sinners—he prayed for their guidance.
Beyond our immediate community, Ramadaan also demands that we reflect on broader injustices. The recent statement by Chief Rabbi Warren Goldstein disregards the lived realities of Palestinians suffering under Israeli occupation. His refusal to acknowledge apartheid policies and the ongoing genocide mirrors historical efforts to erase the oppressed. As South Africans, we must stand firm in our moral stance against Zionism and its violation of human rights.
Ramadaan is a time of spiritual renewal, but it is now also a time for moral clarity. We cannot isolate personal piety from the urgent social and political issues of our time. As we fast, we must ask: Will we foster mercy and justice, or will we allow self-righteousness to masquerade as religiosity? Our faith demands that we choose justice, compassion, and truth—without compromise.
