Muslim Views
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Local
    • National
    • World
    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    • National
    • World
    • Local
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Columnists
    • Discussions with Dangor
    • Editorial
    • Guest Writer
    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

  • Features
    • All
    • 1500 Years of Prophetic Legacy
    • AWQAF SA
    • General Features
    • Imam Abdullah Haron
    • Tributes
    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Arts
    • Books
    • Education
    • Food
    • Health
    • Motoring
    • Sport
    • Technology
    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

  • Finance
    • All
    • Islamic Finance
    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    What our wealth should build

    What our wealth should build

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

  • Islam
    • All
    • Eid
    • Faith and Practice
    • Family
    • Hajj and Umrah
    • Moulood
    • Quran
    • Ramadaan
    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

  • Archives
  • Donate
  • WhatsApp Channel
Muslim Views
  • News
    • All
    • Local
    • National
    • World
    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    • National
    • World
    • Local
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Columnists
    • Discussions with Dangor
    • Editorial
    • Guest Writer
    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

  • Features
    • All
    • 1500 Years of Prophetic Legacy
    • AWQAF SA
    • General Features
    • Imam Abdullah Haron
    • Tributes
    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Arts
    • Books
    • Education
    • Food
    • Health
    • Motoring
    • Sport
    • Technology
    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

  • Finance
    • All
    • Islamic Finance
    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    What our wealth should build

    What our wealth should build

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

  • Islam
    • All
    • Eid
    • Faith and Practice
    • Family
    • Hajj and Umrah
    • Moulood
    • Quran
    • Ramadaan
    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

  • Archives
  • Donate
  • WhatsApp Channel
No Result
View All Result
Muslim Views

The killing of the Imam Haron: probable homicide or murder?

23 December 2022 - Updated on 15 August 2024
in Imam Abdullah Haron, FEATURES
Reading Time: 9 mins read
A A
The killing of the Imam Haron: probable homicide or murder?

Johannes Burger, the only living policeman that interacted with Imam Abdullah Haron whilst he was detained by the apartheid security police in 1969, gives evidence at the inquest in November. (Photo ANWAR OMAR)

Share on WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on Twitter

DRAWING on the testimony of various experts who gave evidence at the inquest last month into the death in detention of Imam Abdullah Haron in 1969, ANWAR OMAR argues that there is only one conclusion that Judge Daniel Thulare can reach when the inquest resumes next year for a ruling.

The inquest into the death of Imam Abdullah Haron, which took place from November 7 to 16, 2022 in the Cape Town High Court commenced with the testimony of an aeronautics engineer and fall trajectory specialist, Thivash Moodley, who conclusively demonstrated that the bruises on the late Imam’s body did not match that of someone who fell down a flight of stairs, in terms of the type of bruises, where it was located on the Imam’s body, as well as when it occurred in terms of timing.

Aeronautical engineer and trajectory specialist, Thivash Moodley, on the flight of stairs where Imam Abdullah Haron was claimed by his interrogators to have slipped. Moodley debunked that account. (Photo ABDURAHMAN KHAN)

In fact, it seems that the narrative of ‘falling down a flight of stairs’ was totally fabricated. The absence of abrasions, the timing of the injuries, as well as the bruises between the lower limbs are completely inconsistent with falling down a staircase.

The inquest continued with Dr Itumeleng Molefe, the state-appointed forensic pathologist and Dr Segaran Ramalu Naidoo, the pathologist for the Haron family, both experts in their field debunking myocardial ischemia as the cause of death of the Imam, as well as linking the latter to a fall down a flight of stairs.

Dr Itumeleng Molefe (Photo CASSIEM KHAN)

According to them, to conclusively prove that myocardial ischemia was indeed the cause of death, the forensic pathologist conducting the autopsy on 28 September 1969, would have had to open the arteries of the deceased to determine whether it was indeed blocked. This was not done and therefore myocardial ischemia cannot conclusively be considered as the cause of death of the Imam. They also found the link between the fall down the stairs and myocardial ischemia quite bizarre and not backed up by the physical evidence of the deceased.

Dr Naidoo’s testimony was quite damning and pointed out several shortcomings in the post-mortem performed by Dr T G Schwar, the apartheid state appointed pathologist who conducted the autopsy on the late Imam Haron in September 1969.

It is important to note that Dr Naidoo has, to date, conducted more than 10 000 similar autopsies. He described the various bruises on the Imam’s body in detail in terms of where they were located, how they were possibly inflicted, how much they had healed and thus approximately when they had occurred.

According to Dr Naidoo, the injuries were severe and extensive in nature covering approximately 560 square centimetres in extent. This was 10-fold greater than the 50 square centimetres of bruising considered to be moderately severe under normal circumstances by the medical literature and yet Dr Schwar insisted, when questioned during the 1971 inquest, that ‘in relation to the whole body it was not extensive’.

You may also want to read

Inaugural Islamic Expo to be hosted in Cape Town

Inaugural Islamic Expo to be hosted in Cape Town

31 March 2026
Tribute to a dedicated doctor, life-long student and peer

Tribute to a dedicated doctor, life-long student and peer

25 September 2025 - Updated on 26 September 2025
Clergy and activists on the step of St George’s Cathedral.

A Journey of Witness — Dr Fatima Hendricks and the return of a moral language

23 October 2025
No place for Urdu in India?

No place for Urdu in India?

1 August 2022 - Updated on 28 August 2024

India to South Africa : how two activists defied their family legacies to challenge injustice

20 May 2024 - Updated on 22 May 2024
Mapping and combatting Islamophobia

Mapping and combatting Islamophobia

10 April 2024 - Updated on 28 August 2024

Dr Naidoo also explained that the ‘wounding threshold’ or the threshold to cause injury, especially on well-padded areas such as the buttocks and lower limbs, was most probably caused by repetitive blows to those areas in order to exceed the injury threshold to cause those injuries. He is therefore of the opinion that the 27 bruises found on the Imam’s body can easily be multiplied by a factor of 2, 3 or 4 if the injury threshold is taken into consideration.

Dr Segaran Ramalu Naidoo (Photo ANWAR OMAR)

Furthermore, Dr Naidoo is of the opinion that the extent of these injuries, which he described as a ‘crushing syndrome’, caused the actual muscle fibres to disintegrate and were carried by the blood stream causing them to clog up the kidneys resulting in acute kidney or renal failure. In his opinion this is a classic case of ‘crushing syndrome’ causing renal failure. However, a proper histology examination and analysis was never conducted and therefore this could not be determined by the 1969 post-mortem. Any physician, when viewing the extent of the injuries, would have conceded that these injuries were severe. Therefore, for Dr Schwar to insist under cross-examination during the 1971 inquest that they were not is very disturbing. It is clear that Dr Schwar was attempting to minimise the impact of the injuries on the well being of the Imam.

Dr Naidoo discussed the 27 injuries in detail and presented a clear perspective on their location and approximately when they occurred.

He then presented a timeline of the bruises in three categories:

  1. Bruises on upper body around the chest area, including a fracture not visible on the outside indicating a more advanced stage of healing and therefore one-and-a-half to two months old. In other words, these injuries were inflicted during the earlier phase of the Imam’s incarceration.
  2. The bruises predominantly on the hip and lower limbs, the upper calf, the rear of the right knee, inside of the thighs and back of the Achilles heel were strikingly large and should be considered very significant in extent. Almost all were on thick and dense tissue indicating that the Imam was probably lying on the floor and repetitively beaten for these injuries to be inflicted ten days before death. The timing of these injuries roughly coincides with the missing ‘two nights and three days’ that was attempted to be concealed by the investigating officers during the 1971 inquest.
  3. The bruises on the lower limbs, largely directed injuries to the shins, which are a few days old.

The debilitating effect would have been enormous as these bruises reflect continuous torture and coupled with over four months in solitary confinement, it would have taken its toll on Imam’s mental health.

The Imam was removed from Maitland Police Station on the morning of September 17, 1969 and only returned after 9pm on the evening of September 19.

The security police deliberately concealed this information as they did not want the Imam to be examined by a physician given his extensive injuries which were obviously very visible and apparent at that stage. Instead, a Captain Geldenhuys administered Doloxene, a very strong opium-based tablet, which was from his personal stash of medication.

The evidence suggests that this ‘missing two nights and three days’ was a dramatic turn in the Imam’s condition and that he complained no less than five times about his condition in the days immediately thereafter. This coincides with the timing of the injuries to the lower torso and lower limbs. There was most definitely a surge in injuries to the Imam’s body and consequently more complaints about the pain that he was experiencing in the days after September 19 and the days immediately prior to his death on September 27.

The timeline reflected by the injuries as described by Dr Naidoo just doesn’t fit the timeline provided by the security branch of the apartheid police.

They claim the Imam fell down the flight of stairs on September 19 and, if they did not torture the Imam, the injuries identified during the autopsy should all be around this time. However, Dr Naidoo identified the upper body injuries around the chest area to be a few months old, probably during the earlier part of the Imam’s detention.

Additionally, September 19 coincides with the last day of the ‘missing two nights and three days’ when the Imam was neither at Caledon Square Police Station nor at Maitland Police Station, and therefore could not have fallen down a flight of stairs at either location. Furthermore, the bruises that do coincide with this period are not reflective of a staircase fall but rather, as described by Dr Naidoo, of a crushing or pounding nature. It is therefore more likely that the Imam was taken to a location outside of Cape Town and severely tortured over these few days and nights.

It was against this background that the inquest proceedings culminated on the sixth and seventh days with the advocate for the Haron family, Howard Varney, questioning Brigadier Johannes Burger, the only living policeman that interacted with Imam Abdullah Haron whilst he was detained by the apartheid security police in 1969. Burger was the policeman who was responsible for the key to the padlock of the cell in which the Imam was held at the time.

Burger related how, whilst on his shift, he and the Imam shared pleasantries about their respective families and sport, particularly rugby and that he spoke to the Imam on September 26, 1969, the day before he died.

He testified how he observed that the demeanour of the Imam was lethargic to the extent that he enquired whether the Imam wanted to see a doctor. To this the Imam replied that he was tired and would like to return to his cell.

The following day the Imam was discovered lying on the floor in a foetal-like position; a posture reflecting the despair and desperation that the Imam was in before he died. According to Burger he did not observe any of the injuries on the Imam’s body, except that the Imam was rubbing an area on the left side of his chest.

Burger further testified that it was only 51 years later, in 2020, when he was shown the autopsy report that he realised the truth and conceded that ‘Hierdie man was gemartel!’ (‘This man was tortured’).

Despite him at one stage becoming quite emotional, seemingly shedding a tear and apologising to the Haron family, he quickly recovered his composure and almost immediately continued his testimony in an extremely arrogant and evasive manner.

Varney put it to Burger that, given the evidence before the court, it was obvious that the Imam was continuously tortured throughout his incarceration and his physical resistance progressively weakened until he died. It was thus very strange that Burger was not aware of what was happening to the Imam over several months whilst in custody.

Varney made the compelling argument that if the police, including Burger, neglected to provide the Imam with medical attention it amounted to probable homicide. However, if they deliberately and consciously prevented the Imam from obtaining medical attention it amounted to murder.

Advocate Howard Varney (Photo ABDURAHMAN KHAN)

Varney made the compelling argument that if the police, including Burger, neglected to provide the Imam with medical attention it amounted to probable homicide. However, if they deliberately and consciously prevented the Imam from obtaining medical attention it amounted to murder. In response, Burger complained to the judge he felt Varney was threatening him. When he didn’t get any favourable response from Judge Thulare, he arrogantly replied to Varney, ‘dis jou volle reg om so ‘n stelling te maak, maar ek bly by my verklaring’ (‘It’s your full right to make such a statement, but I’m sticking to my testimony’).

In my view, the evidence currently at the disposal of the court points in the direction of murder as apposed to probable homicide for the following reasons, bearing in mind, that the security police and uniformed police would have had to act deliberately and consciously to prevent the Imam from obtaining medical attention during those last few days before his death when he complained several times about his medical condition:

  1. Imam Haron complained no less than five times over several days about various pains he was experiencing.
  2. The Imam was not referred to a physician. Instead, a Captain Geldenhuys provided the Imam with Doloxene, a very strong opium-based tablet from his personal medication, indicating that Geldenhuys was aware of the severe pain the Imam was in. It also indicates that the security police did not want the Imam to be examined by a physician in order to conceal the extent of his injuries. At that stage the injuries would have been apparent to any physician.
  3. Geldenhuys argued that it was a weekend and therefore a physician was not available. However, according to Dr Naidoo, this was not true as a physician would most definitely have been on call.
  4. Over the months the Imam was incarcerated he was allowed a clean set of clothes on a weekly basis. However, during the week before his death, his family was not allowed to provide him with clean clothing, again suggesting that the security police were deliberately hiding the condition of his clothes, and thus the physical condition of the Imam, from his family.
  5. The Imam did not fall down a flight of stairs at Caledon Square. It is clear that this was a fabricated narrative to cover-up the fact that the Imam was continuously tortured over several months, and more severely during the ‘two nights and three days’ that was unaccounted for. And they attempted to conceal this during the 1971 inquest.
  6. The security police deliberately tried to conceal the fact that the Imam was neither at Caledon Square Police Station nor at Maitland Police Station from the morning of September 17 and only returned after 9pm on the evening of September 19, 1969.
  7. It was initially suggested that the Imam fell down the stairs at the Maitland Police Station but when this was rejected as not being possible the narrative of the Imam falling down a flight of stairs at Caledon Square Police Station was fabricated. This again suggests that the security police concealed the actual reason for the Imam’s death.
  8. The timing of the fall from the stairs at Caledon Square Police Station was supposedly on the September 19, 1969 but the records show that the Imam was neither at Caledon Square nor at Maitland Police Station, so how could he have fallen there when he wasn’t there?
  9. Dr Schwar clearly tried to minimise the injuries of the Imam, despite the physical evidence reflecting the opposite. According to Dr Naidoo this reflects his ‘dual loyalty’ to his profession as a medical practitioner and to the security branch police, who in this case were effectively his employers.
  10. Several shortcomings in the autopsy report were identified by both Dr Naidoo and Dr Molefe, again suggesting that the autopsy report was ‘made to fit’ the fabricated narrative of a fall down a flight of stairs presented to the court during the 1971 inquest.
  11. The evidence of several witnesses who were incarcerated before and after the Imam, including Jeremy Cronin, Yousuf Gabru, Robert Wilcox, Diane Sandler and Shirley Gunn, all reflect the brutal and inhumane modus operandi of the security police in general, and JP ‘Spyker’ van Wyk and his brother, Andries van Wyk, in particular.

In light of the above, it is my opinion that Judge Tulare has no alternative but to conclude that the Imam was systemically tortured over several months, culminating in the period September 17 to 19, which the security police deliberately tried to conceal, resulting in extensive injuries that eventually caused the Imam’s death on September 27, 1969.

Based on the distinction made by Advocate Howard Varney, between probable homicide and murder, this in my opinion is clearly murder!

An abridged version of this article was first published in the December 16, 2022 print edition of Muslim Views.

Share on WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on Twitter

Subscribe to our Newsletters

* indicates required
Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive
Advertisement

You may also want to read

Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu
FEATURES

Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

19 November 2026
Riding together: Community and the person we become
FEATURES

Riding together: Community and the person we become

18 November 2026
Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online
FEATURES

Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

13 November 2026
Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres
FEATURES

Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

10 November 2026
Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community
Tributes

Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

3 November 2026 - Updated on 5 November 2026
Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice
FEATURES

Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

2 November 2026
November 2026

November 2026

FILE SIZE : 5.6 MB
Download
Advertisement

Latest News

Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

19 November 2026

Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

19 November 2026

Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

19 November 2026

CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

19 November 2026

Riding together: Community and the person we become

18 November 2026

Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

18 November 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
ABOUT MUSLIM VIEWS
About Us
Archives
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Contact Us
Donate to Muslim Views
NEWS
Local
National
World
OPINION
Columnists
Discussions with Dangor
Editorial
Guest Writers
FEATURES
AWQAF SA
Imam Abdullah Haroon
Tributes
FINANCE
Islamic Finance
ISLAM
Eid
Faith and Practice
Family
Hajj and Umrah
Moulood
Quraan
Ramadaan
LIFESTYLE
Arts
Books
Education
Food
Health
Motoring
Sport
Technology

© Muslim Views 2026. All Rights Reserved

Design by: theimagehouse

Loading...

[mc4wp_form id=6780]

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • OPINION
    • Columnists
    • Discussions with Dangor
    • Editorial
    • Guest Writer
  • FEATURES
    • AWQAF SA
    • Imam Abdullah Haron
    • Tributes
    • 1500 Years of Prophetic Legacy
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Arts
    • Books
    • Education
    • Food
    • Health
    • Motoring
    • Sport
    • Technology
  • FINANCE
    • Islamic Finance
  • ISLAM
    • Eid
    • Faith and Practice
    • Family
    • Hajj and Umrah
    • Moulood
    • Quran
    • Ramadaan
  • ARCHIVES
  • DONATE