Muslim Views
No Result
View All Result
  • News
    • All
    • Local
    • National
    • World
    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    • National
    • World
    • Local
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Columnists
    • Discussions with Dangor
    • Editorial
    • Guest Writer
    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

  • Features
    • All
    • 1500 Years of Prophetic Legacy
    • AWQAF SA
    • General Features
    • Imam Abdullah Haron
    • Tributes
    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Arts
    • Books
    • Education
    • Food
    • Health
    • Motoring
    • Sport
    • Technology
    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

  • Finance
    • All
    • Islamic Finance
    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    What our wealth should build

    What our wealth should build

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

  • Islam
    • All
    • Eid
    • Faith and Practice
    • Family
    • Hajj and Umrah
    • Moulood
    • Quran
    • Ramadaan
    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

  • Archives
  • Donate
  • WhatsApp Channel
Muslim Views
  • News
    • All
    • Local
    • National
    • World
    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Rashid Chopdat wants Muslim youth to play a bigger role in society

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Manuel invitation sparks objections over Neville Alexander’s radical legacy

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Two mosques, one Imam: Grieving Garden olives for Gaza take root in Claremont

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Yusuf Khan Dalwai appointed Al Jama-ah deputy to drive grassroots expansion

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    Habibia Siddique Muslim Brigade’s community service spanning over seven decades

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UCT alumni probe epistemicide, scholasticide and holocide in Palestine

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    UUCSA concludes AGM and high-impact outreach sessions in Cape Town

    • National
    • World
    • Local
  • Opinion
    • All
    • Columnists
    • Discussions with Dangor
    • Editorial
    • Guest Writer
    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Election debates, media power and democratic fairness in South Africa

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    Beyond representation: Why Muslim identity is not Islamic consciousness

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

  • Features
    • All
    • 1500 Years of Prophetic Legacy
    • AWQAF SA
    • General Features
    • Imam Abdullah Haron
    • Tributes
    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Riding together: Community and the person we become

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Read the latest edition of Muslim Views online

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Moosa Kaprey honoured for lifelong struggle for justice, education and community

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    Local government elections: bridging political theory and political practice

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    AI can write the thesis, but can it develop the scholar?

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Gaza, the ballot and the MJC fatwa: a religious test before local elections

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Faith in motion: remembrance, discipline and action on the Hijra Cycle Tour

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    Tribute to Comrade Moosa Kaprey: a life of struggle, faith and service

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    The siege of Masjid-us-Salaam: when the mimbar faced Apartheid Casspirs

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Hijra Cycle Tour: how repetition, renewal and discipline shapes us

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    Ebrahim Carelse: remembering an Apartheid-era killing more than 40 years on

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    The remarkable story of Haneen of Gaza

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

    Imam Haron’s legacy unites Ubuntu, faith and the struggle for justice

  • Lifestyle
    • All
    • Arts
    • Books
    • Education
    • Food
    • Health
    • Motoring
    • Sport
    • Technology
    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Federation legends mark 20 years of preserving non-racial soccer heritage

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    Hassan Howa book launch turns tribute into a challenge for South African sport

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    The life of Nabi Musa comes alive on stage

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    Ummah Tech 2026: Building faith-driven technology for lasting impact

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Islamic thought meets modern cosmology in a compelling new book

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Breaking the stigma surrounding mental health in the Muslim community

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Rooted in his faith, Ruiters says his book has a message for all South Africans

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Nabil Yasien Mohamed explores Ghazali’s enduring search for certainty

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

    Reading the Prophet: knowing the sīrah, reading ourselves

  • Finance
    • All
    • Islamic Finance
    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    Future-ready Islamic Investing

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    How “green-halal” sukuk are reshaping South African and global ethical finance

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    Before you trust the promise, find out what your money is really doing

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    FIFC 2026: a historic gathering helps shape the future of Islamic finance

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    Beyond compliance: rethinking Islamic investment ethics

    What our wealth should build

    What our wealth should build

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Cape Town to host global leaders exploring the future of ethical Islamic finance

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Beyond the handshake: Protecting family business and the people behind it

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

    Your will is written, but who will fund the estate?

  • Islam
    • All
    • Eid
    • Faith and Practice
    • Family
    • Hajj and Umrah
    • Moulood
    • Quran
    • Ramadaan
    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    Scholarship, Sufism, and wasatiyyah: The living mandate of the Soofie centres

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    The sovereign and the ballot: An Islamic perspective

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    Does ta’wīl mean interpretation or fulfilment? A Quranic reassessment [+video]

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    The premodern Sunni roots behind modern Jihadi Salafist political thought

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    Quranic compass to guide global debate on AI, food security and humanity

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    The ‘stemme’ rise: how Cape Mawlid nurtures listening, love and community

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Scholars at Masjidul-Quds Moulood call for everyday integrity

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Prophetic legacy for a world on fire: Iḥsān, adab and agency

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

    Voices of faith: youth, scholars and relics unite for Moulood-un-Nabi

  • Archives
  • Donate
  • WhatsApp Channel
No Result
View All Result
Muslim Views

An argument against compulsory vaccination

A response to Professor Aslam Fataar

8 October 2021 - Updated on 28 August 2024
in Guest Writer
Reading Time: 6 mins read
A A
An argument against compulsory vaccination

A business in New York displaying a sign requiring proof of vaccination prior to entering. The writer argues that there are less restrictive means that can be adopted as a counterweight to mandating people to submit to the taking of a COVID-19 vaccination. (Photo SHUTTERSTOCK)

Share on WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on Twitter

‘Professor Fataar’s argument of gentle persuasion is, in my humble view, unconvincing, to the extent that it assumes as a self-evident truth that the vaccines across the entire spectrum of COVID-19 vaccines are lifesavers, without any serious side effects’, writes ADVOCATE ANWAR ALBERTUS.

WHILE it was not my intention to become involved in a polemic concerning the question whether one should or should not vaccinate, I feel impelled to express a few thoughts about the article authored by Professor Aslam Fataar under the heading ‘Should the unvaccinated be denied entry to mosques?’ which was published on the Muslim Views website on September 21, 2021.

Before I express my humble views on the matter, I deem it important to say upfront, lest it be said that I have succumbed to fake news, that I do not for one moment deny the reality of the COVID-19 virus, along with the illness and death that it has wrought in its wake. I am, furthermore, fully aware of the sterling work performed by medical practitioners and other health professionals in seeking to combat this veritable scourge, and laud them for that.

As the heading to the article shows, Professor Fataar does not simply address the niceties of people’s right to choose whether to be vaccinated or not, he proceeds to deal with the very vexing question whether or not people who refuse to be vaccinated against the COVID-19 virus should be dragooned into being vaccinated on pain of being denied access to various places such as mosques, universities and other places of public resort.

While Professor Fataar admittedly does not argue in favour of compulsory or mandated vaccination, he does, however, seek to encourage everyone to get vaccinated before they enter public places like schools, mosques and shops, arguing in the process that educational, media and other tactics of persuasion and education must be prioritised to spread the overall health and welfare measures in which the message of vaccination is key. He, however, contends that banning persons from attending mosques may be too blunt and that, given the considerable number of people who refuse to take the vaccine in our community, ‘we should keep a line of mercy and guidance open to everyone in our community’ … ‘persuasion via education is critical. We should build solidarity alliances and influence our communities to advance our pro-vaccination educational campaigns and religious messaging.’ [My emphasis].

Reading between the lines, it would appear that the thrust of the article is not so much concerned with advancing the common good of the hesitant ones in the community but rather with the protection of the health of the ones who have already been vaccinated. This is confirmed by the author’s acceptance without more that the so-called vaccine hesitancy in the Muslim community constitutes a challenge to those who have already been vaccinated. This assertion classically begs the question, insofar as it is posited on a number of assumptions which the author has not at all essayed to interrogate and prove, whether by reference to accredited studies on the subject, the effectiveness and safety of the various COVID-19 vaccines available in the market or otherwise.

Given the fact that the author contends that the challenge is to those who have been vaccinated, to convince those who have not been vaccinated, to undergo vaccination, it is not insignificant to note that the number of people who have, according to the most recent reports, been fully vaccinated up to now is 7,91 million, which represents only 13,5 per cent of our total adult population of 59,62 million. These statistics are rather telling within the context of the discourse as to whether people who have not been vaccinated should be compelled by those who have, to submit to vaccination. On the present numbers, as to who have been vaccinated, there can be little doubt that compelling the so-called hesitant ones to be vaccinated will, on a macro scale (leaving aside for the moment, the Muslim community), be tantamount to allowing the minority in this country to dictate to the majority, which, needless to say, is undemocratic.

Professor Fataar’s argument of gentle persuasion is, in my humble view, unconvincing, to the extent that it assumes as a self-evident truth that the vaccines across the entire spectrum of COVID-19 vaccines are lifesavers, without any serious side effects, whether in the acute, medium or long-term phases. Contrary to this assumption, there is more than sufficient clinical and anecdotal evidence of people dying from debilitating symptoms or contracting the virus again, after taking the jab.

Supplementary to this is the fact that there are countless physicians and academics across the various disciplines within the field of medicine, who are of the considered view that the COVID-19 vaccines will, over the next two to three years, have serious side effects for those who have been vaccinated. One of the concerns which I, accordingly, have with the article is that it does not deal with this divergent body of opinion within the medical fraternity. It would appear that it is simply relegated to oblivion under the guise of fake news.

Professor Fataar further argues, as a general proposition, that the decision to close any premises applies to situations where there is a likelihood of spreading the virus in close contact situations, such as schools, universities etc. While this is admittedly so, the problem with this argument is that, at present, the COVID-19 third wave seems to be dissipating. However, as the author himself admits, there are established ways of mitigating this risk, which are manageable by those in control of these places, such as making compulsory the wearing of masks, sanitising the hands and maintaining safe distances. In addition to these safety protocols, many mosques hold two sessions for the Friday compulsory congregational prayers in order to facilitate appropriate social distancing.

Professor Fataar further contends that the decision about limiting mosque access to the vaccinated must balance the need to secure the conditions to guarantee the right to life with showing compassion and mercy to those who may hold a different view. Here again, the author assumes, without empirical evidence, that vaccination guarantees without more, the right to life. In short, he seems to uncritically accept that the vaccine is an unqualified panaceum for the COVID-19 virus. He adopts this proposition without drawing on any accredited studies, which then leads him ineluctably to conclude that the only factor weighing in favour of the so-called hesitant ones is the compassion and mercy of those who have been vaccinated.

Professor Fataar’s thesis, unfortunately, does not only trivialise the counter-argument of those who refuse to be vaccinated, it is also unduly condescending towards them insofar as it assumes that their decision not to vaccinate is based on ignorance and/or simple sentiment and/or bigotry and/or religious fervour. His thesis, moreover, overlooks the fact that there is no credible evidence that all or even most of those who have been vaccinated did so willingly and with informed consent. On the contrary, there is evidence to the effect that many of those who have been vaccinated were coerced into doing so by their employers. On this aspect of the matter it should be observed that there is a legal distinction between consent and submission. The following simple example of this distinction will suffice: a robber cannot be heard to say that his victim consented to giving him his wallet when, in truth, he held a gun to the victim’s head. Should Professor Fataar require proof of employer coercion, I will gladly furnish him with the name of an attorney, who specialises in labour law, who has received countless complaints in this regard.

Professor Fataar says that legal scholars have argued that compulsory vaccination would pass constitutional or legal muster. However, I respectfully disagree. The mandating of vaccination of the so-called hesitant ones will, in my respectful view, not pass constitutional scrutiny for a number of reasons, one of which is that, in terms of the limitation clause in our Constitution, a factor to be taken into consideration before any fundamental right is limited, is whether there are less restrictive measures which can be adopted to achieve the end being sought.

As Professor Fataar himself concedes, there are indeed less restrictive measures which can be adopted to mitigate the spreading of the COVID virus, namely, compulsory sanitising of hands, the wearing of face masks and social distancing. In addition thereto, most public places require, as a safety measure, the taking of one’s temperature before admission. Furthermore, as already adverted to herein, many mosques, at the compulsory congregational prayers on Fridays, hold two sessions in order to facilitate adequate social distancing.

In sum, aside from the fact that there are less restrictive means that can be adopted as a counterweight to mandating people to submit to the taking of a COVID-19 vaccination, an additional fact which militates against any such mandate is that there is, within the medical fraternity, a not insignificant body of opinion against the propriety of being vaccinated. It is the latter fact which I believe really bedevils the entire question whether it is prudent or not to take the jab. On this issue, I pause to observe that, in terms of section 12(2)(c) of our Constitution, everyone has the right to bodily and psychological integrity, which includes the right not to be subjected to medical or scientific experiments without their informed consent.

I, for one, have not sought to persuade anyone in my family to decide one way or the other. The matter is, for me, strictly one of personal choice based on informed consent.

You may also want to read

Cultivating divine relationality: Towards an education able to protect students in the age of artificial intelligence

Cultivating divine relationality: Towards an education able to protect students in the age of artificial intelligence

10 June 2025
Tracking the journey leading to the recognition by the courts of Muslim marriages

Tracking the journey leading to the recognition by the courts of Muslim marriages

20 June 2023 - Updated on 28 August 2024
Mapping national and provincial heritage at the Mowbray Muslim Cemetery

Mapping national and provincial heritage at the Mowbray Muslim Cemetery

29 May 2026
The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

26 January 2022
Dr Mofokeng goes out on top – despite attempts to distract her

Dr Mofokeng goes out on top – despite attempts to distract her

6 August 2026

India to South Africa : how two activists defied their family legacies to challenge injustice

20 May 2024 - Updated on 22 May 2024

In conclusion, while I do not accept as convincing the argument sought to be made out by Professor Fataar for the setting afoot of campaigns to urge the so-called hesitant ones within the Muslim community to take the jab, I do appreciate his softer approach, as opposed to the hard-line attitude of others, especially amongst the Muslim clergy, who are agitating for mandated vaccinations and exclusion from mosques of the unvaccinated.

M A Albertus SC is a practising advocate at the Cape Bar, and former chairperson of the Cape Bar Council and former acting judge of the Western Cape High Court.

Share on WhatsappShare on FacebookShare on Twitter

Subscribe to our Newsletters

* indicates required
Choose the newsletters you'd like to receive
Advertisement

You may also want to read

Riding together: Community and the person we become
FEATURES

Riding together: Community and the person we become

18 November 2026
Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice
OPINION

Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

18 November 2026
Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state
OPINION

Between Mandela and Morsi: Imran Khan and the sadism of the Pakistani state

17 November 2026
Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters
Islamic Finance

Future-ready Islamic investing: why financial discipline still matters

13 November 2026
US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu
World

US midterms: shocking results deal devastating blow to Trump and Netanyahu

6 November 2026
Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth
Local

Global resilience grows as AI investment supports third-quarter growth

6 November 2026
November 2026

November 2026

FILE SIZE : 5.6 MB
Download
Advertisement

Latest News

Black October, day by day: a Cape Muslim family record of the 1918 Spanish flu

19 November 2026

Cape Town youth shine at Madrasatul Quds and Fusion Inyameko Foundation quiz

19 November 2026

Towards a fiqh of artificial intelligence: An Islamic ethical framework

19 November 2026

CTUB and global partners address Islamophobia and civic responsibility

19 November 2026

Riding together: Community and the person we become

18 November 2026

Beyond Islamophobia: Building solidarity against all forms of injustice

18 November 2026
Advertisement
Advertisement
ABOUT MUSLIM VIEWS
About Us
Archives
Terms & Conditions
Privacy Policy
Contact Us
Donate to Muslim Views
NEWS
Local
National
World
OPINION
Columnists
Discussions with Dangor
Editorial
Guest Writers
FEATURES
AWQAF SA
Imam Abdullah Haroon
Tributes
FINANCE
Islamic Finance
ISLAM
Eid
Faith and Practice
Family
Hajj and Umrah
Moulood
Quraan
Ramadaan
LIFESTYLE
Arts
Books
Education
Food
Health
Motoring
Sport
Technology

© Muslim Views 2026. All Rights Reserved

Design by: theimagehouse

Loading...

[mc4wp_form id=6780]

No Result
View All Result
  • NEWS
    • Local
    • National
    • World
  • OPINION
    • Columnists
    • Discussions with Dangor
    • Editorial
    • Guest Writer
  • FEATURES
    • AWQAF SA
    • Imam Abdullah Haron
    • Tributes
    • 1500 Years of Prophetic Legacy
  • LIFESTYLE
    • Arts
    • Books
    • Education
    • Food
    • Health
    • Motoring
    • Sport
    • Technology
  • FINANCE
    • Islamic Finance
  • ISLAM
    • Eid
    • Faith and Practice
    • Family
    • Hajj and Umrah
    • Moulood
    • Quran
    • Ramadaan
  • ARCHIVES
  • DONATE