• Archives
  • Contact Us
  • Distribution
  • Advertising
  • Membership
Thursday, June 30, 2022
Muslim Views

  • News
    • All
    • Community
    • Featured
    • International
    • National
    Hajj of the heart

    Hajj of the heart

    Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

    Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

    Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022

    Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022

    Bonteheuwel High School to host several events to mark Youth Month

    Bonteheuwel High School to host several events to mark Youth Month

    Roundtable puts Arabic on the local map

    Roundtable puts Arabic on the local map

    The activist who cared for the needy

    The activist who cared for the needy

    Trending Tags

    • Finance
    • Features
      • All
      • Arts
      • Awqaf
      • Books
      • Discussions with Dangor
      • Family
      • From Consciousness to Contentment
      • Health File
      • Hungry for Halaal
      • In Memoriam
      • Motoring
      • Sport
      • Survivor's Blog

      Refugees and the internally-displaced: the forgotten people of the ummah

      How Mufti Taha Karaan inspired a master calligrapher

      How Mufti Taha Karaan inspired a master calligrapher

      The activist who cared for the needy

      The activist who cared for the needy

      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      The long wudu

      The long wudu

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

      Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

    • Living Islam
      • All
      • Eid-ul-Adha
      • Eid-ul-Fitr
      • Hajj Stories
      • Light from the Quran
      • Moulood-un-Nabi
      • Quran
      • Ramadaan
      Hajj of the heart

      Hajj of the heart

      The long wudu

      The long wudu

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

      Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

      The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

      The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

      Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

      Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

    • Opinion
      • All
      • Editorial
      • Guest Writer
      • Letters to the editor
      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

      The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      The nation’s sister

      The nation’s sister

      The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

      The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

      Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

      Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

    • About Us

      About Us

      Advertising

      Newpaper Archives

      LEGAL

      Terms & Conditions

      Privacy Policy

    No Result
    View All Result

    No products in the cart.

    • News
      • All
      • Community
      • Featured
      • International
      • National
      Hajj of the heart

      Hajj of the heart

      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

      Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022

      Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022

      Bonteheuwel High School to host several events to mark Youth Month

      Bonteheuwel High School to host several events to mark Youth Month

      Roundtable puts Arabic on the local map

      Roundtable puts Arabic on the local map

      The activist who cared for the needy

      The activist who cared for the needy

      Trending Tags

      • Finance
      • Features
        • All
        • Arts
        • Awqaf
        • Books
        • Discussions with Dangor
        • Family
        • From Consciousness to Contentment
        • Health File
        • Hungry for Halaal
        • In Memoriam
        • Motoring
        • Sport
        • Survivor's Blog

        Refugees and the internally-displaced: the forgotten people of the ummah

        How Mufti Taha Karaan inspired a master calligrapher

        How Mufti Taha Karaan inspired a master calligrapher

        The activist who cared for the needy

        The activist who cared for the needy

        Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

        Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

        The long wudu

        The long wudu

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

        Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

      • Living Islam
        • All
        • Eid-ul-Adha
        • Eid-ul-Fitr
        • Hajj Stories
        • Light from the Quran
        • Moulood-un-Nabi
        • Quran
        • Ramadaan
        Hajj of the heart

        Hajj of the heart

        The long wudu

        The long wudu

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

        Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

        The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

        The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

        Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

        Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      • Opinion
        • All
        • Editorial
        • Guest Writer
        • Letters to the editor
        Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

        Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

        Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

        Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

        Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

        Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

        The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

        The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

        The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

        The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        The nation’s sister

        The nation’s sister

        The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

        The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

        Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

        Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

      • About Us

        About Us

        Advertising

        Newpaper Archives

        LEGAL

        Terms & Conditions

        Privacy Policy

      No Result
      View All Result
      Muslim Views
      No Result
      View All Result
      • News
      • Living Islam
      • Features
      • Opinion
      • Finance
      • Imam Haron
      Home News Featured

      The Saudi distortion of dissent in Islam

      May 25, 2022
      in Featured
      Reading Time: 7 mins read
      A A
      The Saudi distortion of dissent in Islam

      On March 7, 2018, hundreds of people protested in London outside Downing Street against the visit of Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed Bin Salman. The protest marked just over one thousand days into the Saudi bombing of Yemen, which is almost entirely supported by the United Kingdom and the United States. (Photo ALISDARE HICKSON/CREATIVE COMMONS)

      Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsappShare on Email

      ZIYAD MOTALA cites examples from the time of the Prophet (SAW) and the caliphs to illustrate how the Saudis’ reaction to a peaceful protest near the Prophet’s (SAW) resting place against a delegation of Pakistani politicians is a distortion of the right of dissent in Islam.

      A POWERFUL event of peaceful protest occurred on April 28, 2022, in the Saudi kingdom, at the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque – something not seen in Madinah for over fourteen hundred years. A visiting delegation of Pakistani politicians, including Prime Minister Shahbaz Sharif and two ministers from the recently installed government, were greeted by worshippers repeatedly chanting ‘chor’, which in English translates as ‘thief’.

      Did Prime Minister Sharif, who is out on bail on multiple criminal charges for alleged financial improprieties, visit the holy places to burnish his religious bona fides to a citizenry back home? If that were the case, the optics of what happened has had the opposite effect. The images of the protest have been relayed and amplified with commentary and gone viral on social media. For adherents of the Islamic faith, being called a ‘thief’ near the resting place of Prophet Muhammad (SAW) is a profound jolt. It has been interpreted by many as signifying that these politicians were not worthy of traversing such sacred terrain.

      As was expected, the Saudi authorities who brook no dissent were incensed by the protests. Politically, one can understand the Saudis’ concern. Protests of ‘chor’ against Pakistani officials if left unchecked could blossom to protests against Saudi governance or human rights violations. The Madinah police have since arrested five suspects for ‘abusing and insulting’ the Pakistani ministers. The spokesperson for the police remarked that the actions of the protesters is against Islam and ‘contradict the sanctity of the place’. The protest took place a distance from the Prophet’s (SAW) grave.

      Islamic scholars, all the way back to Caliph Omar and the Prophet’s (SAW) wife, Ayesha (RA), instructed Muslims not to raise their voices next to the Prophet’s (SAW) grave. Understandably, political discourse and protests in the mosque even far from the grave of the Prophet (SAW) would undermine the worship of other pilgrims. Given the crowds, time, manner and place, restrictions on protest are needed. But the notion that no protests are permitted in Islam or that political discourse never took place in the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque is incorrect. The efforts of smart phones and citizen reporting of the incident offers a monumental teachable moment for Muslims and others about the correct Islamic conception of democracy, freedom of speech and accountability of government officials for malfeasance.

      The Saudis and ‘freedom’ of speech
      There is a litany of Prophetic examples that illustrate the Saudi view of freedom of speech and protest, like so much of their brand of Islam, is the antithesis of Islamic scriptures and Prophetic (SAW) practice. Islamic scriptures are replete with calls on every Muslim to enjoin good and forbid wrong. Muslims unanimously agree that the Prophet (SAW) proclaimed that speaking against an unjust ruler is the highest form of sacrifice in the path of God. Muslims also unanimously concur that the Prophet (SAW) said when you see a wrong, change it with your hand. If you cannot change it with your hand then speak against the wrong. And if you cannot change the wrong with your words then despise that wrong in your heart but that is the lowest level of faith.

      There are many examples of freedom of speech and protest in the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque, or during the pilgrimage during the life of the Prophet (SAW) and the four immediate successors of the Prophet (SAW), who Sunni Islam unanimously proclaims as the four noble or rightly guided caliphs. Their instructions and examples represent sources of Islamic law. Here are a few illustrations.

      The Prophet (SAW) was once delivering a speech and a man interrupted the Prophet (SAW) and inquired about the unlawful detention of his neighbour. The man rose two more times and asked the same question. Thereafter, the Prophet (SAW) asked the police officer to release the man’s neighbour. The incident is instructive at several levels. First, it occurred in the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque. Second, it was the Prophet (SAW) that was being interrupted. Third, the Prophet (SAW) did not say that the interruption disrespected him or his mosque. Fourth, the Prophet (SAW) recognised the validity of someone concerned about injustice and raising the concern publicly.

      On assuming office after he was selected leader of the state after the Prophet’s (SAW) death, Abu Bakr, the first noble caliph, addressed the community and remarked, ‘You have made me your leader although I am in no way superior to you. Co-operate with me when I do right; correct me when I err.’ He also said, ‘Turn away from me when I deviate.’ Abu Bakr admonished the community that if he errs and departs from ethical principles, which by definition preclude corruption, immorality and injustice, the community has an obligation to speak truth to power.

      Meanwhile, Saudi Crown Prince Mohamed Bin Sultan recently asked the Saudi population to accept austerity measures while personally spending about half a billion United States dollars on a supposed Salvador Mundi painting of Christ, which turned out to be a fake. Islamic tenets demand that the public must hold leaders accountable for their actions. Caliph Abu Bakr stated, ‘[T]o tell the truth to a person commissioned to rule is faithful allegiance; to conceal it is treason.’

      Dynasty vs khilaafah
      Abu Bakr recognised the equality of society, which is replete in the sayings of the Prophet (SAW). The legitimacy of Abu Bakr’s leadership was not derived from dynastic rule. The subsequent three caliphs were also selected through a process of mutual consultation, which arguably represented the first implementation of a rudimentary democracy; rule by consensus as opposed to coercion. It was also a rejection of hereditary leadership. On his deathbed, the second caliph, Omar, asked for a consultative committee of the leading personalities of the time to choose his successor. Omar was absolutely emphatic that his successor could not be his son, thus eschewing dynastic rule.

      Neither the Prophet (SAW) – considered by Muslims as the greatest personality that lived – nor the caliphs gave the state their family name. The Saudi state is named after the ruling family and constitutes an absolutist, dynastic and family-centred government, the members of whom have amassed enormous wealth. The family treats the resources and treasury as their private piggy bank.

      Caliph Abu Bakr warned his officials against making state appointments based on nepotism or leaders enriching themselves. On assuming office, Caliph Abu Bakr asked his daughter to take stock of his assets so that a determination could be made at the end whether he had been enriched in office. This might be the earliest recorded instance of a leader concerned about corruption, and providing a self-imposed check against corruption.

      Limits to obedience
      Like his predecessor, the second caliph, Omar, instructed the Muslim community that no leader should be obeyed if he acts against the tenets of the faith. Omar remarked that the community has rights over him and must be able to enforce those rights. Omar took meticulous measures to ensure that political power was not an entrance to richness. For example, he asked every officer he appointed to take a pledge that they would live simply and eat simply. Those who breached the rule were reported by the citizenry and were sanctioned. A detailed inventory of the assets of the officials was prepared at the time of their appointment and reassessed at the end of their tenure. The officials had to account for any increases in their assets.

      The Saudi monarchy and the sycophant clerics on the government payroll distort material aspects of Islam to justify and fortify the survival of the Al Saud dynasty. They demand absolute obedience to a ruler. This is an inversion of Islamic teachings and contradict historical examples concerning issues of justice, morality and corruption being addressed in the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque or during the pilgrimage.

      Caliph Omar was confronted in public in the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque and in the streets by ordinary people who raised concerns about inappropriate behaviour by government officials. Omar protected the right of a person who once interrupted his speech, and is reported to have said, ‘If the people do not give me good advice they are useless, and if I do not listen to it, I am useless.’ On another occasion, Omar asked the assembly what they would do if he, Omar, strayed from the straight path? A man stood up and responded he would confront Omar and even suggested he would take up arms against him. Omar replied, ‘Praise be to God that among my people are present men who could put me on the straight part if I deviated from it.’

      A distortion of Islam
      The Saudis demand that the pilgrimage and visits to the holy mosques be conducted as an exclusive exercise of rituals and individual spirituality – a reflection and strengthening of the individual’s relationship with God in a morally blind manner. The Prophet (SAW) and the caliphs conducted political and military meetings in the Prophet’s (SAW) mosque. The caliphs Omar and Uthman required their senior government officials come to Makkah at the time of the annual pilgrimage and people were encouraged to voice any complaints they might have had against any official. Omar is known to have taken action against aberrant government officials during these occasions.

      The Saudi rulers distort the comprehensive Islamic injunction of enjoining good and forbidding evil, and turn it on its head to preclude any questioning of their rule. In doing so, they offer an obtuse and destructive assault on absolute principles of justice, ethics, morality and good governance, which in Islam cannot be derogated from.

      The protest in Madinah in the last week of Ramadaan did not happen next to the Prophet’s (SAW) grave, which would have been problematic. Not since the time of the noble caliphs have we seen this sort of peaceful rebuke of public officials, albeit not Saudi, in the first Muslim capital. The protest offers Muslims an opportunity for self-reflection beyond the positivist diet fed by absolute dictators that they are owed unquestionable obedience by virtue of their hold on power.

      Caliphs Abu Bakr and Omar rebuked an inert or indifferent citizenry and ordered them to hold their leaders publicly accountable. The Prophet (SAW) and the noble caliphs would not countenance illegitimate or dynastic rule, profligacy, corruption, authoritarianism, human rights violations, the slaughter of civilians in Yemen or Saudi support for repression in Egypt and Palestine.

      The obligation to enjoin good and forbid evil requires every Muslim to talk out against these abuses. The concept of deen – that Islam is an all-encompassing way of life – requires the rejection of Saudi and other brands of Islam that pigeonhole Islam as sanitised rituals, devoid of moral, ethical and political dimensions.

      Professor Ziyad Motala was born in South Africa and is Professor of law at Howard University School of Law, in Washington DC. He served as an Honorary Professor of Law at the University Of Western Cape School of Law and is currently director of the Howard South Africa Summer Abroad Programme. Motala is the co-author, with Cyril Ramaphosa, of ‘Constitutional Law Analysis and Cases’.
      This article was first published in https://muslimmatters.org/

       

      Previous Post

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      Next Post

      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      Related Posts

      Hajj of the heart
      Eid-ul-Adha

      Hajj of the heart

      June 30, 2022
      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy
      Featured

      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

      June 10, 2022
      Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022
      Featured

      Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022

      June 9, 2022
      Next Post
      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      Book Review: Islam and Evolution: Al-Ghazālī and the Modern Evolutionary Paradigm by Shoaib Malik

      Latest News

      Eid-ul-Adha

      Hajj of the heart

      June 30, 2022
      Featured

      Dudula Movement exposes systemic failure and lack of civic education and political literacy

      June 10, 2022
      Featured

      Reflections on the Cape Town International Islamic Finance Conference 2022

      June 9, 2022
      Discussions with Dangor

      Refugees and the internally-displaced: the forgotten people of the ummah

      June 8, 2022

      Browse by Tags

      Stellenbosch University NPA Shaikh Seraj GBV Sanzaf sexual abuse COVID-19 Palestine gender based violence Prophet Muhammad Eid-ul-Fitr Imam Haron Steve Biko Seraj Hendricks Sulaiman Nordien
      Muslim Views Logo
      GET IN TOUCH

      About Us

      Contact Us

      Newspaper Archives

      Terms & Conditions

      Privacy Policy

      WEBSITE SITEMAP

      NEWS

      National

      Local

      Community

      International

      BUSINESS

      Focus on Finance

      FEATURES

      Arts for All

      AWQAF

      Discussions with Dangor

      From Consciousness to Contentment

      Family

      Fusion Lifestyle

      Health File

      Hungry for Halaal

      In Memoriam

      Motoring

      Sport

      Survivor's Blog

      LIVING ISLAM

      Ramadaan

      Eid-ul-Fitr

      Hajj Stories

      Eid-ul-Adha

      Moulood-un-Nabi

      Quran

      Sunnah

      Hadith

      Light from the Quran

      OPINIONS & ANALYSIS

      Editorial

      Guest Writers

      Letter to the Editor

      © Muslim Views 2021. All Rights Reserved
      Website Developed by: Icon Designs
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Finance
        • Focus on Finance
      • Features
        • Arts
        • Awqaf
        • Discussions with Dangor
        • From Consciousness to Contentment
        • Fusion Lifestyle
        • Health File
        • Hungry for Halaal
        • In Memoriam
        • Motoring
        • Sport
        • Survivor’s Blog
      • Living Islam
        • Eid-ul-Adha
        • Eid-ul-Fitr
        • Family
        • Hadith
        • Hajj Stories
        • Light from the Quran
        • Moulood-un-Nabi
        • Quran
        • Ramadaan
        • Sunnah
      • News
        • Community
        • International
        • National
      • Opinion & Analysis
        • Editorial
        • Guest Writer
        • Letters to the editor
      • Print Archives
      • About Us
      • Contact Us

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
      Cookie SettingsAccept All
      Manage consent

      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
      Necessary
      Always Enabled
      Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
      CookieDurationDescription
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
      viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
      Functional
      Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
      Performance
      Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
      Analytics
      Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
      Advertisement
      Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
      Others
      Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
      SAVE & ACCEPT

      Add New Playlist

      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?