• Archives
  • Contact Us
  • Distribution
  • Advertising
  • Membership
Tuesday, May 17, 2022
Muslim Views

  • News
    • All
    • Community
    • Featured
    • International
    • National
    Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

    Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

    The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

    The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

    The long wudu

    The long wudu

    Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

    Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

    The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

    The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

    Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

    Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

    Trending Tags

    • Business
    • Features
      • All
      • Arts
      • Awqaf
      • Books
      • Discussions with Dangor
      • Family
      • From Consciousness to Contentment
      • Health File
      • Hungry for Halaal
      • In Memoriam
      • Motoring
      • Sport
      • Survivor's Blog
      The long wudu

      The long wudu

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

      Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

      Take care of your skin throughout summer – and beyond

      Take care of your skin throughout summer – and beyond

      The nation’s sister

      The nation’s sister

      The joint IMA community health and masjid project in Langa, Cape Town

      The joint IMA community health and masjid project in Langa, Cape Town

      In discussion with Qaanitah Hunter

      In discussion with Qaanitah Hunter

    • Living Islam
      • All
      • Eid-ul-Fitr
      • Hajj Stories
      • Light from the Quran
      • Moulood-un-Nabi
      • Quran
      • Ramadaan
      The long wudu

      The long wudu

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

      Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

      Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

      The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

      The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

      Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

      Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      Understanding the true nature of this world

      Allah Almighty: The True Beloved

    • Opinion
      • All
      • Editorial
      • Guest Writer
      • Letters to the editor
      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

      The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

      The nation’s sister

      The nation’s sister

      The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

      The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

      Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

      Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

      Vaccinated or not? The oncoming mosque storm

      Vaccinated or not? The oncoming mosque storm

      An argument against compulsory vaccination

      An argument against compulsory vaccination

    • About Us

      About Us

      Advertising

      Newpaper Archives

      LEGAL

      Terms & Conditions

      Privacy Policy

    No Result
    View All Result

    No products in the cart.

    • News
      • All
      • Community
      • Featured
      • International
      • National
      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      The long wudu

      The long wudu

      Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

      Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

      The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

      The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

      Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

      Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

      Trending Tags

      • Business
      • Features
        • All
        • Arts
        • Awqaf
        • Books
        • Discussions with Dangor
        • Family
        • From Consciousness to Contentment
        • Health File
        • Hungry for Halaal
        • In Memoriam
        • Motoring
        • Sport
        • Survivor's Blog
        The long wudu

        The long wudu

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

        Muhammad Bin Salman a threat to Islamic values

        Take care of your skin throughout summer – and beyond

        Take care of your skin throughout summer – and beyond

        The nation’s sister

        The nation’s sister

        The joint IMA community health and masjid project in Langa, Cape Town

        The joint IMA community health and masjid project in Langa, Cape Town

        In discussion with Qaanitah Hunter

        In discussion with Qaanitah Hunter

      • Living Islam
        • All
        • Eid-ul-Fitr
        • Hajj Stories
        • Light from the Quran
        • Moulood-un-Nabi
        • Quran
        • Ramadaan
        The long wudu

        The long wudu

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Perspectives on physical and mental health during Ramadaan

        Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

        Ramadaan: pursuing taqwa through tazkiyah

        The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

        The Holy Quran, Our Salvation: Ramadaan reflections

        Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

        Taking control of your life this Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Supporting breastfeeding during Ramadaan

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        Understanding the true nature of this world

        Allah Almighty: The True Beloved

      • Opinion
        • All
        • Editorial
        • Guest Writer
        • Letters to the editor
        Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

        Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

        The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

        The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

        The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

        The hijab ban ruling in India: courts used as political instruments

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        Stop the march of intolerance and incivility

        The nation’s sister

        The nation’s sister

        The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

        The fight for a more equal and just America to fulfill MLK’s dream

        Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

        Hamas tells UK: ‘Your decision is a crime against the oppressed’

        Vaccinated or not? The oncoming mosque storm

        Vaccinated or not? The oncoming mosque storm

        An argument against compulsory vaccination

        An argument against compulsory vaccination

      • About Us

        About Us

        Advertising

        Newpaper Archives

        LEGAL

        Terms & Conditions

        Privacy Policy

      No Result
      View All Result
      Muslim Views
      No Result
      View All Result
      • News
      • Living Islam
      • Features
      • Opinion
      • Business
      • Imam Haron
      Home News Featured

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      May 11, 2022
      in Featured, Guest Writer, Opinion & Analysis
      Reading Time: 7 mins read
      A A
      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      The Reverend Dr Stephen Sizer will be appearing in the Bishop’s Disciplinary Tribunal for the Diocese of Winchester from Monday, May 23 to Friday, May 27, 2022, arising from a complaint made by the Board of Deputies of British Jews. (Photo Supplied)

      Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsappShare on Email

      In 2018, the Board of Deputies of British Jews lodged a complaint against Reverend Dr Stephen Sizer, the former vicar of the Anglican parish of Christ Church, in Surrey, England, accusing him of anti-Semitism. DR REEDERWAN CRAAYENSTEIN presents his arguments in support of Dr Sizer, whose Tribunal is scheduled for May 23 – 27, in Central London.

      I COME from the anti-apartheid struggle and live in the UK. I am writing to the church in solidarity with Dr Sizer. I hope that in recalling the role of the church in the anti-Apartheid struggle in South Africa, that the Tribunal might have a richer context to consider the charges against Dr Sizer.

      Remember that four human rights organisations accuse Israel of being an Apartheid state; that it commits crimes against humanity; that the international community has a legal duty under the 1968 Apartheid Convention and the 1998 Rome Statute to do everything that it can to bring an end to this Apartheid regime. Dr Sizer is doing what he can to hold an Apartheid regime to account. His accusers routinely defend that regime.

      Dr Sizer stands accused of engaging in anti-Semitic actions that are incompatible with being a serving officer of the church.

      An accusation of anti-Semitism is controversial and vague. I admit that hatred of the Jewish people is endemic in Europe, and the Holocaust has been a catastrophe of unimaginable proportions. Being critical of the actions of a state can hardly be anti-Semitic. No one accused anti-Apartheid activists in South Africa of being anti-white or anti-Afrikaner or racist.

      To accuse Dr Sizer of anti-Semitism assumes that there is a consensus, agreed, uncontroversial standard of what constitutes anti-Semitism. We have competing definitions e.g. International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) and the Jerusalem Definition of Anti-Semitism. They lead to different conclusions. For the accusers of Dr Sizer, every criticism of Israel is anti-Semitic as per the IHRA. That means that the conclusions of Yesh Din, B’Tselem, Human Rights Watch and Amnesty International are that Israel is an Apartheid state that commits crimes against humanity.

      They call for the international community to hold Israel to account in terms of the 1968 Apartheid Convention and the 1998 Rome Statute. In terms of these two international instruments, Israel cannot continue committing crimes against humanity inside Israel against its 20 per cent Arab population against whom it structurally discriminates; it cannot continue to apply two sets of laws and policies over Jewish and Arab people in the one geographic area between the river and the sea where it alone is the sovereign power.

      Dr Sizer is known to oppose Israel as an Apartheid state. That puts him at odds with his accusers, who are not known to have ever come out in radical criticism of the actions of Israel as commanded in the Bible. Jeremiah says, ‘Do not stand idly by the bloodstained shirt of your neighbour.’ Apartheid in Israel systematically creates bloodstained shirts.

      Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel says that indifference to evil is worse than evil itself. Dr Sizer has chosen to answer the call of Jeremiah and Rabbi Abraham Joshua Heschel. Israel cannot exist as an Apartheid state. It must treat its Arab citizens as equal to its Jewish citizens. It must end the occupation of the Palestinian and Syrian territories from 1967 until today. It must allow for the right of return of Palestinian refugees in terms of international law. Israel cannot be a Jewish state that is founded on war crimes, crimes against humanity, violations of international law, breaches of international humanitarian law, politically at odds with norms in the UN General Assembly, routinely ignoring UN Security Council resolutions.

      Dr Sizer’s accusers cannot allow a serving cleric to be a prophetic voice in England echoing the prophetic voice of Jerusalem and the Bible. Yet, the legal case, the political case, the case in terms of international law, humanitarian law, moral law favour not his accusers but Dr Sizer, the accused.

      It is not Dr Sizer alone who stands accused. I recall Cannon Collins, of St Paul’s Cathedral, and Archbishop Trevor Huddleston, Dr Beyers Naude, Reverend Alan Boesak, Dr Frank Chikane, who were lighthouses to the ships as we fought against Apartheid South Africa. They were involved in declaring Apartheid in South Africa to be a heresy. The tradition of the prophets of Jerusalem led them to accuse the perpetrators of Apartheid and call them to return to the Jesus who loves all the children of the world, the Jesus who died for all the children of the world. Jesus loves widows, orphans and foreigners.

      Dr Sizer has not even gone to where these anti-Apartheid clergy and churches had gone. Even Sabeel-Kairos is not there yet. An Apartheid system creates widows, orphans and foreigners. Where would Jesus stand today? Why is Dr Sizer being accused for raising questions that the prophets of Jerusalem, including Jesus would have raised? He should not stand accused. On the contrary, the church might consider giving him a standing ovation in public, and a radical critique in private. But, he stands accused against the backdrop of an Apartheid state.

      This is not the first time that Dr Sizer stands accused by the same fraternity. This is an accusation that goes back ten years, at least. His accusers suggest that he spends an inordinate amount of time on anti-Semitic activity. One could respond that his accusers are spending a similar amount of time either trying to bully and harass or stalking him online. When Conciliation Meeting concluded in 2012, his accusers did not accept in good faith. On the contrary, they reiterated their accusation, at the conclusion. That is arguably un-Christian.

      Dr Sizer has been followed, if not stalked, by his accusers when he left parish ministry. His support for Jeremy Corbyn and comments on the people who also now accuse him, was taken as further evidence of anti-Semitism. Dr Sizer was accused of anti-Semitism when he referred to Israel’s alleged role in bringing down Jeremy Corbyn. There was a TV series on this subject, where members of the Labour Party were collaborating with staff at the Israeli Embassy on the subject of Jeremy Corbyn. His accusers are silent about this documentary series.

      One could argue that Dr Sizer is being singled out because he stands out in the Anglican Church as being critical of injustice in Israel-Palestine. But Dr ML King, today celebrated by the African American Church, was unwelcome in most of the black churches during the days of the civil rights campaign. Prophets are usually unpopular amongst their own people. One need not always agree with his choice of words, company that he keeps or social media platforms that he uses. But, he is on the right side of the argument legally, politically, from a human rights, humanitarian, moral and spiritual perspective. Dr Sizer stands accused because he dares to lift his head above the parapet in the Church of England.

      Why did the church not discipline Cannon Collins or Archbishop Trevor Huddleston when they took a stand against Apartheid South Africa? Why did the Anglican Church not discipline Nobel Laureate Archbishop Desmond Tutu, who played a role in the anti-Apartheid struggle, turned St George’s Cathedral into a sanctuary for prayer and resistance right next door to the Apartheid House of Parliament? Yet, that same Arch Tutu was able to use that moral force to call the anti-Apartheid resistance to order when it burnt enemies alive.

      Dr Sizer can play a Canon Collins, Archbishops Huddleston and Tutu role as the church recalibrates to find its voice on Apartheid Israel. He is not a problem. He is probably a path to a solution for the church. Sanctioning him will place the church in a moral and spiritual cul de sac on Apartheid Israel. After all, the church has hardly dealt with the legacy of slavery that haunts the UK.

      The Anglican Church should not be disciplining, monitoring and silencing Dr Sizer. On the contrary, what would Jesus do when faced with an Apartheid state? What does the Anglican Church, and the accusers of Dr Sizer say about ‘Christ at the Checkpoint?’

      This is not a trial for Dr Sizer. One would not be uncharitable to say that this is a Kairos and Road to Damascus moment for the Church of England. Yesh Din has spoken, B’Tselem has spoken. They are Israeli human rights organisations. The two biggest human rights organisations in the world have spoken. Israel is an Apartheid state.

      Israel is the sole sovereign power between the river and the sea. Hamas and the Palestinian Authority are irrelevant when it comes to deciding anything in Israel-Palestine. Israel applies two sets of standards to two ethnic communities in one geographic area, with the sole purpose to ensure the domination of Jews over Arabs in terms of access to land and resources. That is Apartheid they say. This is a moral, spiritual and existential catastrophe, from the church perspective. The prophets of Jerusalem would not hesitate to place the charges against Dr Sizer in this context.

      I would further suggest that this context of Apartheid and the prophetic legacy of Jerusalem should be the frame within which the accusations against Dr Sizer should be considered. Without this framework, empathy will likely be in short supply.

      The Anglican Church played a significant role in the struggle against Apartheid in South Africa. There, the regime was buttressed by the Dutch Reformed Church. Not only should the church understand the Apartheid context in which Dr Sizer stands accused but the church itself has to find its own prophetic voice on Apartheid in Israel. The facts are not in dispute. The prophets of Jerusalem need voices to be raised.

      Dr Sizer has had ten years, at least of having to deal with what amounts to stalking, harassment and bullying. No one did this to Canon Collins or Archbishop Huddleston. All that I am appealing for is moral consistency. Apartheid anywhere is a crime against humanity.

      The church is under pressure to impose severe sanctions against Dr Sizer. But, in any inquiry the sanctions is a balancing act between retribution, deterrence, incapacitation and rehabilitation. The accusers want Dr Sizer to be completely silenced and dissociated from the church. They are opposed to Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) against an Apartheid state but they want BDS to be applied to DR Sizer.

      Imposing sanctions is probably the most severe actions that the Tribunal can impose on Dr Sizer. In doing so, there is no right or wrong answer. There are only better, and the accusers of Dr Sizer would want a more severe sanction than October 2012. The aim is likely to shut down any criticism given that human rights organisations agree that Israel is an Apartheid regime.

      Sanctions are a combination of relevant church regulations, logic, reason and empathy. The church would not easily argue that Israel is not an Apartheid state. In fact, a workshop with the four human rights organisations would be a positive step for the church. The bible and prophets of Jerusalem would hardly argue in favour of a system that creates the bloodstained shirts that horrify Jeremiah. But sanctioning Dr Sizer would institutionalise the standing by idly that causes Jeremiah sleepless nights and days.

      Dr Raul Hilberg, the founder of Holocaust Studies, in his ‘The Destruction of European Jewry’ says that there were perpetrators, victims and bystanders. The question facing the church, in light of its role in the struggle against Apartheid South Africa is: will it institutionalise bystanders who stand idly by? Or will it encourage its followers as it did in the days of Apartheid South Africa?

      The regulations of the church, the reasoning of the prophets of Jerusalem, the logic of the bible and empathy would suggest that Dr Sizer should not be sanctioned. Ten years of arguably being harassed, bullied, trolled and stalked by his accusers have been stressful enough. Acquit Dr Sizer and advise him to continue on his prophetic Anglican journey while remaining self-critical so that he does not slip into a dogmatic position that could blinker his otherwise important contribution to call for an Israel-Palestine where there is justice for all, irrespective of differences.

      Let Dr Sizer be a bridge to a prophetic role for the church on Apartheid Israel. Despite the protestations of his accusers, Israel stands accused of crimes against humanity. Will the church play the role that it played against Apartheid in South Africa? Sanctioning Dr Sizer is not a step along that path.

      Previous Post

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      Related Posts

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer
      Featured

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      May 11, 2022
      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa
      Featured

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      April 22, 2022
      The long wudu
      Featured

      The long wudu

      April 6, 2022

      Latest News

      Featured

      Standing in solidarity with Dr Sizer

      May 11, 2022
      Featured

      The place of Cape Town in a burning South Africa

      April 22, 2022
      Featured

      The long wudu

      April 6, 2022
      Features

      Exercise guidelines for Ramadaan

      April 5, 2022

      Browse by Tags

      COVID-19 Sanzaf Eid-ul-Adha Palestine Cassiem Khan Galiema Haron GBV NPA gender based violence Imam Abdullah Haron Stellenbosch University Eid-ul-Fitr Shaikh Seraj Steve Biko Imam Haron
      Muslim Views Logo
      GET IN TOUCH

      About Us

      Contact Us

      Newspaper Archives

      Terms & Conditions

      Privacy Policy

      WEBSITE SITEMAP

      NEWS

      National

      Local

      Community

      International

      BUSINESS

      Focus on Finance

      FEATURES

      Arts for All

      AWQAF

      Discussions with Dangor

      From Consciousness to Contentment

      Family

      Fusion Lifestyle

      Health File

      Hungry for Halaal

      In Memoriam

      Motoring

      Sport

      Survivor's Blog

      LIVING ISLAM

      Ramadaan

      Eid-ul-Fitr

      Hajj Stories

      Eid-ul-Adha

      Moulood-un-Nabi

      Quran

      Sunnah

      Hadith

      Light from the Quran

      OPINIONS & ANALYSIS

      Editorial

      Guest Writers

      Letter to the Editor

      © Muslim Views 2021. All Rights Reserved
      Website Developed by: Icon Designs
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Business
        • Focus on Finance
      • Features
        • Arts
        • Awqaf
        • Discussions with Dangor
        • From Consciousness to Contentment
        • Fusion Lifestyle
        • Health File
        • Hungry for Halaal
        • In Memoriam
        • Motoring
        • Sport
        • Survivor’s Blog
      • Living Islam
        • Eid-ul-Adha
        • Eid-ul-Fitr
        • Family
        • Hadith
        • Hajj Stories
        • Light from the Quran
        • Moulood-un-Nabi
        • Quran
        • Ramadaan
        • Sunnah
      • News
        • Community
        • International
        • National
      • Opinion & Analysis
        • Editorial
        • Guest Writer
        • Letters to the editor
      • Print Archives
      • About Us
      • Contact Us

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
      Cookie SettingsAccept All
      Manage consent

      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
      Necessary
      Always Enabled
      Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
      CookieDurationDescription
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
      viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
      Functional
      Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
      Performance
      Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
      Analytics
      Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
      Advertisement
      Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
      Others
      Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
      SAVE & ACCEPT

      Add New Playlist

      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?