• About Us
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Distribution
  • Legal
    • Privacy Policy
    • Terms and Conditions
Thursday, December 7, 2023
Muslim Views

  • News
    • All
    • Community
    • Featured
    • International
    • National
    Seminar to address increasing interest in Islamic psychology

    Seminar to address increasing interest in Islamic psychology

    Police Ombudsman urges public to report GBV during 16 Days of Activism

    Police Ombudsman urges public to report GBV during 16 Days of Activism

    INX Prime wins Brave Journalism Award

    INX Prime wins Brave Journalism Award

    Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

    Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

    Leading Pakistani jurist rallies for Palestine

    Leading Pakistani jurist rallies for Palestine

    Exceptional talent shines at provincial speech competition

    Exceptional talent shines at provincial speech competition

    Trending Tags

    • Finance
    • Features
      • All
      • Arts
      • Awqaf
      • Books
      • Discussions with Dangor
      • Education
      • Family
      • From Consciousness to Contentment
      • Health File
      • Hungry for Halaal
      • In Memoriam
      • Motoring
      • Sport
      • Survivor's Blog
      Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently

      Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently

      Remembering Alexander Sinton High’s Nabil Swart who spoke truth to power

      Remembering Alexander Sinton High’s Nabil Swart who spoke truth to power

      African Muslim Intellectual History

      African Muslim Intellectual History

      Islamic mortgage bond to fund home solar energy?

      Islamic mortgage bond to fund home solar energy?

      Kariema Davids writes her way into thousands of hearts

      Kariema Davids writes her way into thousands of hearts

      Tracing the family leads to ancestor banished in chains to the Cape

      Tracing the family leads to ancestor banished in chains to the Cape

      War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

      War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

      A critique of neo-traditionalists: Hamza Yusuf, Abdal Hakim Murad and Umar Faruq Abd Allah

      A critique of neo-traditionalists: Hamza Yusuf, Abdal Hakim Murad and Umar Faruq Abd Allah

      IMAM HARON – Commemorating a lifetime of resistance and activism

      IMAM HARON – Commemorating a lifetime of resistance and activism

    • Living Islam
      • All
      • Eid-ul-Adha
      • Eid-ul-Fitr
      • Hajj Stories
      • Light from the Quran
      • Moulood-un-Nabi
      • Quran
      • Ramadaan
      African Muslim Intellectual History

      African Muslim Intellectual History

      Muslims are rallying around the climate emergency

      Muslims are rallying around the climate emergency

      The attractive mosque with a bankrupt worshipper

      The attractive mosque with a bankrupt worshipper

      Food sharing in Ramadaan and getting closer to Allah

      Food sharing in Ramadaan and getting closer to Allah

      Towards a value-enhancing Ramadaan

      Towards a value-enhancing Ramadaan

      True happiness here and in the hereafter

      True happiness here and in the hereafter

      Public talk on the study of Islam and gender

      Public talk on the study of Islam and gender

      Understanding the true nature of this world

      A Quranic perspective on change

      The hajj as an ethical structure of forgiveness

      The hajj as an ethical structure of forgiveness

    • Opinion
      • All
      • Editorial
      • Guest Writer
      • Letters to the editor
      Hamas prisoner exchange and Israel’s genocidal war: context is crucial

      Hamas prisoner exchange and Israel’s genocidal war: context is crucial

      Apartheid victims’ families must proceed with claims in the interests of justice

      Apartheid victims’ families must proceed with claims in the interests of justice

      Neutrality is complicity: If you don’t condemn Gaza genocide then you support it

      Neutrality is complicity: If you don’t condemn Gaza genocide then you support it

      The colonial roots of the suffering of the Palestinians

      The colonial roots of the suffering of the Palestinians

      Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

      Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

      The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

      The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

      The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

      The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

      War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

      War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

      Will Israel survive the 2023 war?

      Will Israel survive the 2023 war?

    • Print Archives
    • DONATE
    No Result
    View All Result

    No products in the cart.

    • News
      • All
      • Community
      • Featured
      • International
      • National
      Seminar to address increasing interest in Islamic psychology

      Seminar to address increasing interest in Islamic psychology

      Police Ombudsman urges public to report GBV during 16 Days of Activism

      Police Ombudsman urges public to report GBV during 16 Days of Activism

      INX Prime wins Brave Journalism Award

      INX Prime wins Brave Journalism Award

      Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

      Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

      Leading Pakistani jurist rallies for Palestine

      Leading Pakistani jurist rallies for Palestine

      Exceptional talent shines at provincial speech competition

      Exceptional talent shines at provincial speech competition

      Trending Tags

      • Finance
      • Features
        • All
        • Arts
        • Awqaf
        • Books
        • Discussions with Dangor
        • Education
        • Family
        • From Consciousness to Contentment
        • Health File
        • Hungry for Halaal
        • In Memoriam
        • Motoring
        • Sport
        • Survivor's Blog
        Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently

        Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently

        Remembering Alexander Sinton High’s Nabil Swart who spoke truth to power

        Remembering Alexander Sinton High’s Nabil Swart who spoke truth to power

        African Muslim Intellectual History

        African Muslim Intellectual History

        Islamic mortgage bond to fund home solar energy?

        Islamic mortgage bond to fund home solar energy?

        Kariema Davids writes her way into thousands of hearts

        Kariema Davids writes her way into thousands of hearts

        Tracing the family leads to ancestor banished in chains to the Cape

        Tracing the family leads to ancestor banished in chains to the Cape

        War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

        War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

        A critique of neo-traditionalists: Hamza Yusuf, Abdal Hakim Murad and Umar Faruq Abd Allah

        A critique of neo-traditionalists: Hamza Yusuf, Abdal Hakim Murad and Umar Faruq Abd Allah

        IMAM HARON – Commemorating a lifetime of resistance and activism

        IMAM HARON – Commemorating a lifetime of resistance and activism

      • Living Islam
        • All
        • Eid-ul-Adha
        • Eid-ul-Fitr
        • Hajj Stories
        • Light from the Quran
        • Moulood-un-Nabi
        • Quran
        • Ramadaan
        African Muslim Intellectual History

        African Muslim Intellectual History

        Muslims are rallying around the climate emergency

        Muslims are rallying around the climate emergency

        The attractive mosque with a bankrupt worshipper

        The attractive mosque with a bankrupt worshipper

        Food sharing in Ramadaan and getting closer to Allah

        Food sharing in Ramadaan and getting closer to Allah

        Towards a value-enhancing Ramadaan

        Towards a value-enhancing Ramadaan

        True happiness here and in the hereafter

        True happiness here and in the hereafter

        Public talk on the study of Islam and gender

        Public talk on the study of Islam and gender

        Understanding the true nature of this world

        A Quranic perspective on change

        The hajj as an ethical structure of forgiveness

        The hajj as an ethical structure of forgiveness

      • Opinion
        • All
        • Editorial
        • Guest Writer
        • Letters to the editor
        Hamas prisoner exchange and Israel’s genocidal war: context is crucial

        Hamas prisoner exchange and Israel’s genocidal war: context is crucial

        Apartheid victims’ families must proceed with claims in the interests of justice

        Apartheid victims’ families must proceed with claims in the interests of justice

        Neutrality is complicity: If you don’t condemn Gaza genocide then you support it

        Neutrality is complicity: If you don’t condemn Gaza genocide then you support it

        The colonial roots of the suffering of the Palestinians

        The colonial roots of the suffering of the Palestinians

        Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

        Prosecuting war crimes in the Israel-Gaza conflict

        The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

        The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

        The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

        The complicity of America in the collapse of international law

        War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

        War on Gaza is to liquidate Palestinians lives

        Will Israel survive the 2023 war?

        Will Israel survive the 2023 war?

      • Print Archives
      • DONATE
      No Result
      View All Result
      Muslim Views
      No Result
      View All Result
      • News
      • Living Islam
      • Features
      • Opinion
      • Finance
      • Imam Haron
      Home Features Books

      Reading Be Careful with Muhammad thirty years later

      Book Review

      October 20, 2021
      in Books, Features, Moulood-un-Nabi
      Reading Time: 5 mins read
      A A
      Reading Be Careful with Muhammad thirty years later

      About 5000 people marched in The Hague to demonstrate in 1988 against Salman Rushdie’s The Satanic Verses. (Photo ROB CROES - https://commons.wikimedia.org)

      Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on WhatsappShare on Email
      Print 🖨 PDF 📄

      NABIL YASIEN MOHAMED

      THIRTY years since its initial publication, Shabbir Akhtar’s second edition (with an extensive additional preface) of Be Careful with Muhammad is as relevant as ever, if not more so. Salman Rushdie’s novel, The Satanic Verses, published in 1988, opened the floodgates to mocking Muhammad (SAW) with the subsequent release of the Danish cartoons in 2005 and the Charlie Hebdo caricatures of Muhammad (SAW) in 2015.

      Akhtar’s classic remains the most authoritative and persuasive critique of Rushdie’s literary terrorism, The Satanic Verses. He argues against the absolutism of free speech, and the necessity for responsible speech. In a lucid manner, Akhtar’s book comprehensively surveys and comments on the events which followed the publication of The Satanic Verses, from the Muslim protests, the book burning in Bradford, the Liberal inquisition on Muslim sentiment to Khomeini’s infamous fatwa to assassinate Salman Rushdie.

      Why is the slander and vilification of Muhammad (SAW) such a sensitive and injurious matter to Muslims? Akhtar pertinently addresses this question in the opening chapter. He states that, unlike the imitation of Christ, the imitation of Muhammad (SAW) is a religious obligation upon all Muslims. Muhammad (SAW) represents the moral ideal upon which Muslims pattern their daily lives; to Muslims he is ‘not dead’ but ideologically alive. His model of righteousness is closely followed with utmost fervour and enthusiasm. Thus, ‘any attack on this holy pattern is already an attack on a Muslim’s own professed ideals,’ says Akhtar. This amounts to an injury more significant than a racial slur or libel, it is an attack on the moral exemplar for almost a quarter of the human race. Akhtar notes that, for Muslims, Islam is part of their identity much like race and gender; an assault on it is an assault on an inescapable part of one’s being.

      Contenders against Rushdie are often criticised for not having actually read The Satanic Verses. In an objective manner, Akhtar does a thorough evaluation of the book, on its literary merit and contentious remarks. He states that the book is not just a work of fiction but its striking resemblance to actual events is a calculated attempt to recast Islamic history in a negative light and assassinate the character of Muhammad (SAW); whom Rushdie names Mahound, a derogatory name Christians used in the Middle Ages to refer to Muhammad (SAW) as the devil.

      Akhtar clearly shows that any authentic Muslim, or even nominal, will rightfully be enraged by Rushdie’s malicious mockery and vicious slander of Muhammad (SAW). For instance, Akhtar states that The Satanic Verses, in crass and vulgar language, describes Mahound as an unscrupulous politician and drunkard. He also describes him as a debauched sensualist whose household is portrayed in pornographic imagery as a brothel. In the brothel, the prostitutes assume the names of Mahound’s wives. Akhtar is in no way averse to debate and legitimate historical criticism but draws the line at ‘scurrilous imaginative writing’.

      In a balanced manner, Akhtar defends the principle of free speech but deems it immoral to, in its name, wage malevolent attacks on a religious tradition. He states that in mature liberal democracies, writers should indeed condemn evil and injustice without the fear of offending, however, they should not tolerate works that ridicule and demean established religious traditions. Akhtar states that the tension is not between freedom of speech versus censorship but disciplined criticism versus Western licence to ridicule and slander.

      He also notes that freedom of speech is not absolute; laws against racial hatred, gender discrimination, libel, blasphemy (as in Britain), obscenity and sedition do exist. He thus advocates for state legislation to prohibit material such as The Satanic Verses to protect religious minorities and maintain social harmony. Thus, such laws will not protect the beliefs per se but ‘they protect the people who hold these beliefs against offence’.

      What gave the Rushdie affair its momentum? Besides its actual hype (from the book burning to Khomeini’s fatwa), Akhtar alludes to a psychic clash of civilisations between Islam and the West; a perpetual tension that exists since the days of the Crusades; a Western animus against Islamic civilisation deeply embedded in its historical memory. Islam has always been an intellectual and political contender of the West, incessantly fringing on its borders. But now a contemporary fear exists of an ever-increasing Muslim presence in the heart of Europe.

      Akhtar states that the expectation for Muslims to swallow and tolerate Rushdie’s literary terrorism is not just a campaign of free speech but cultural imperialism. It is the West that chooses the moral fashion. We dare not express our independence for literary taste, no matter how distasteful it may be. Our rejection of this very sentiment fuels the affair, and enrages the West. Akhtar remarks that it is this ideological battle that is the primary reason for the continuous defence to circulate a ‘relatively inferior piece of literature’.

      Yes, inferior according to Akhtar on the basis of its ambiguity, historical inaccuracies, lack of integrity, flaccid character portrayals and not to mention its wanton inflammatory remarks. He states that it is hard to take Rushdie’s novel seriously as a work of art for it is evident that Rushdie’s intention was not disciplined criticism but unprincipled abuse.

      Akhtar discusses the incident of the ‘satanic verses’ in Islamic history and its inauthenticity, though, provides a cursory glance of it and the opinions of classical Muslim scholars. A topic he does commendably discuss at length is apostasy in the Islamic tradition. In his discussion of apostasy, he recognises that it is punishable by death, though, it is synonymous to treason. He states that Islam values religious freedom (Quran 2:256, 109:6), however, if an act of apostasy is meant to undermine the Islamic political body or actively oppose the House of Islam, the death penalty is issued. He thus remarks that apostasy in and of itself (void of aggravated political and social implications) does not warrant capital punishment.

      Akhtar discusses the broad approval of Khomeini’s fatwa by many Sunni scholars but doesn’t discuss the disapproval of it from other religious bodies or scholars. He comes across approvingly of Khomeini’s fatwa, theologically speaking, but doesn’t recommend implementing it outside the House of Islam. Instead, he recommends campaigning to obtain a state ban of the book.

      Akhtar argues that in a multicultural society it is unwise to allow denigration and abuse for it leads to public disorder but also the marginalisation of minority groups. He states, ‘Muslims want to integrate but not to assimilate: they want to compromise on matters of fashion but not of principle.’ Akhtar shows that multiculturalism has failed in Britain. Muslims’ sacredly held convictions are clearly not taken seriously or respected. Akhtar states, ‘If society deteriorates – as societies can – there will be dire consequences for the defenceless Muslims.’

      Akhtar is a voice of warning; more than thirty years ago he remarked, ‘Next time there are gas chambers in Europe, there is little doubt concerning who will be inside them.’ In the preface to the second edition, he remarks that this was no hyperbole for the world witnessed the genocide of Bosnian Muslims in Europe shortly thereafter; setting the stage for the persecution of Muslims in other parts of the world, from the Rohingya Muslims in Myanmar to the Uyghurs in China, among others.

      Shabbir Akhtar’s book is original, persuasive and timely. More than thirty years after the Rushdie affair, Islamophobia is more rampant than ever. Akhtar’s book remains relevant to the debate on censorship and free speech, and without a doubt the best critique against The Satanic Verses and Salman Rushdie’s campaign against Islam. It is essential reading, deserving a place on everyone’s shelf.

      • An abridged version of this article was published in the October 8, 2021 print edition of Muslim Views.
      Tags: Prophet Muhammad
      Previous Post

      Moulood-un-Nabi: not a day but a lifetime

      Next Post

      Adult Mental Health Awareness during COVID-19

      Related Posts

      Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently
      Books

      Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently

      November 23, 2023
      Remembering Alexander Sinton High’s Nabil Swart who spoke truth to power
      Features

      Remembering Alexander Sinton High’s Nabil Swart who spoke truth to power

      November 9, 2023
      African Muslim Intellectual History
      Features

      African Muslim Intellectual History

      November 14, 2023
      Next Post
      Adult Mental Health Awareness during COVID-19

      Adult Mental Health Awareness during COVID-19

      Latest News

      Community

      Seminar to address increasing interest in Islamic psychology

      December 4, 2023
      Community

      Police Ombudsman urges public to report GBV during 16 Days of Activism

      November 29, 2023
      Opinion & Analysis

      Hamas prisoner exchange and Israel’s genocidal war: context is crucial

      November 24, 2023
      Books

      Good Jew, Bad Jew: new book explores why the west views brutality against Ukrainians and Palestinians differently

      November 23, 2023

      Browse by Tags

      Seraj Hendricks Sulaiman Nordien Imam Haron NPA Ramadaan gender based violence Steve Biko Dr Auwais Rafudeen Sanzaf Eid-ul-Fitr GBV Eid-ul-Adha COVID-19 Palestine Shaikh Seraj
      Muslim Views Logo
      GET IN TOUCH

      About Us

      Contact Us

      Newspaper Archives

      Terms & Conditions

      Privacy Policy

      WEBSITE SITEMAP

      NEWS

      National

      Local

      Community

      International

      BUSINESS

      Focus on Finance

      FEATURES

      Arts for All

      AWQAF

      Discussions with Dangor

      From Consciousness to Contentment

      Family

      Fusion Lifestyle

      Health File

      Hungry for Halaal

      In Memoriam

      Motoring

      Sport

      Survivor's Blog

      LIVING ISLAM

      Ramadaan

      Eid-ul-Fitr

      Hajj Stories

      Eid-ul-Adha

      Moulood-un-Nabi

      Quran

      Sunnah

      Hadith

      Light from the Quran

      OPINIONS & ANALYSIS

      Editorial

      Guest Writers

      Letter to the Editor

      © Muslim Views 2021. All Rights Reserved
      Website Developed by: Icon Designs
      No Result
      View All Result
      • Home
      • Finance
        • Focus on Finance
      • Features
        • Arts
        • Awqaf
        • Discussions with Dangor
        • From Consciousness to Contentment
        • Fusion Lifestyle
        • Health File
        • Hungry for Halaal
        • In Memoriam
        • Motoring
        • Sport
        • Survivor’s Blog
      • Living Islam
        • Eid-ul-Adha
        • Eid-ul-Fitr
        • Family
        • Hadith
        • Hajj Stories
        • Light from the Quran
        • Moulood-un-Nabi
        • Quran
        • Ramadaan
        • Sunnah
      • News
        • Community
        • International
        • National
      • Opinion & Analysis
        • Editorial
        • Guest Writer
        • Letters to the editor
      • Print Archives
      • About Us
      • Contact Us

      Welcome Back!

      Login to your account below

      Forgotten Password?

      Retrieve your password

      Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

      Log In
      We use cookies on our website to give you the most relevant experience by remembering your preferences and repeat visits. By clicking “Accept All”, you consent to the use of ALL the cookies. However, you may visit "Cookie Settings" to provide a controlled consent.
      Cookie SettingsAccept All
      Manage consent

      Privacy Overview

      This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
      Necessary
      Always Enabled
      Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. These cookies ensure basic functionalities and security features of the website, anonymously.
      CookieDurationDescription
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-analytics11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Analytics".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-functional11 monthsThe cookie is set by GDPR cookie consent to record the user consent for the cookies in the category "Functional".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-necessary11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookies is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Necessary".
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-others11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Other.
      cookielawinfo-checkbox-performance11 monthsThis cookie is set by GDPR Cookie Consent plugin. The cookie is used to store the user consent for the cookies in the category "Performance".
      viewed_cookie_policy11 monthsThe cookie is set by the GDPR Cookie Consent plugin and is used to store whether or not user has consented to the use of cookies. It does not store any personal data.
      Functional
      Functional cookies help to perform certain functionalities like sharing the content of the website on social media platforms, collect feedbacks, and other third-party features.
      Performance
      Performance cookies are used to understand and analyze the key performance indexes of the website which helps in delivering a better user experience for the visitors.
      Analytics
      Analytical cookies are used to understand how visitors interact with the website. These cookies help provide information on metrics the number of visitors, bounce rate, traffic source, etc.
      Advertisement
      Advertisement cookies are used to provide visitors with relevant ads and marketing campaigns. These cookies track visitors across websites and collect information to provide customized ads.
      Others
      Other uncategorized cookies are those that are being analyzed and have not been classified into a category as yet.
      SAVE & ACCEPT

      Add New Playlist

      Are you sure want to unlock this post?
      Unlock left : 0
      Are you sure want to cancel subscription?